Tidbits from Reb Meilach a"h · Episode 78 · 25 Elul 5786 · 4:42
Is it really a typo?
Episode description
From a Shiur in Yom Tov Shel R"H 5665
Machine translation into English of the automatic Hebrew transcript.
00:02 Speaker 1 By the way, we can take a good lesson for ourselves from this. [unclear]. Here the wording is “for the sake of a mitzvah.” Telling a non-Jew to perform a melachah prohibited by Torah law is, after all, only a shevus prohibition. That is not good wording. [unclear]. A shevus prohibition is, after all, a rabbinic prohibition. [unclear]. Does it override a Torah prohibition by means of a shevus prohibition? [unclear] a Shabbos prohibition. That is a question [unclear]. It is written in section [unclear]. [unclear] shevus. Right away, there is a different way of looking at it here [unclear]. Is that good or bad? It is not [unclear]. That is how people generally act, but we [unclear]. The approach should be [unclear]. Is that good or bad? It is good. [unclear]. There are nine subsections [unclear]. [unclear]. I remember [unclear]. This is not a story. These are already intricate arguments. [unclear]. A Shabbos prohibition. A shevus prohibition. A prohibition—it is forbidden. Forbidden. [unclear]. That is how it is [unclear]. By the way, this is also [unclear] from Tosafos. [unclear]. There is nothing here. [unclear]. There is much more. Ah.
02:29 Speaker 1 As a rule, after [unclear] Torah law, [unclear]. A prohibition—it is forbidden. That is something you need to know. [unclear]. And I think it is also [unclear]. You are not allowed to drink. I simply do not have time [unclear]. Simply, there is [unclear]. [unclear] Torah law. That is when it does not [unclear] a Torah prohibition. And again [unclear]. But that is the unusual thing [unclear]. It seems [unclear]. It is an entire concern [unclear]. After all, he has [unclear] a Torah prohibition. That too is [unclear]. So perhaps it is [unclear]. It is not [unclear]. Just something. But it is not.
03:25 Speaker 2 Jerusalem already.
03:25 Speaker 1 Jerusalem. One more thing: now is it [unclear]? That is much better. The section is [unclear]. But a rabbinic shevus overrides [unclear]. That too is [unclear]. It is not simple. [unclear] and the halachic authorities [unclear]. [unclear] rabbinic, or only rabbinic. Forbidden. [unclear]. It is terrible. [unclear]? Yes, it is a matter of [unclear] Torah law [unclear], and most of the reasoning is rabbinic, and [unclear] rabbinic concerning a Torah prohibition. And the first time, a prohibition [unclear] rabbinic. A prohibition [unclear] rabbinic, [unclear] a shevus prohibition [unclear]. That is no blessing. It is a foolish thing. But that is the way [unclear]. And from this, students [unclear]. Yes, corrections. Well. Still, on a superficial level, that really is the crux of it. A shevus prohibition is a prohibition. But, but, but [unclear]. It is a Torah prohibition. But [unclear]. Where do you fit that in? [unclear]. It is not forgotten.